Validation Status
Authoritative Validation — 155 / 155 PASS
- Validation targets
- 155
- PASS
- 155
- UNVERIFIED
- 0
- Mismatches
- 0
- Missing targets
- 0
- Computed outputs
- 155
- None outputs
- 0
- Expectation derivation
- workbook_recalculated
- Expectation authoritative
- yes
Expectation Provenance
Recorded provenance of the expectation set (workbook_headline_outputs.json _provenance), verbatim.
- derivation
- workbook_recalculated
- derivative_committed
- false
- derivative_sha256
- 66919d767f89d5de63669e655c9f17c2de2e687a8355a1d13928d470f967c1b6
- engine
- LibreOffice 26.2.4.2 (soffice --headless --convert-to xlsx, isolated profile)
- extracted_at
- 2026-09-08
- gates.edit_guard
- PASSED upstream - 12 text-only cells edited 2026-09-07 through the guarded path (IERRampTimber_38!A2/A11/A44/E7/E17, MethodsRulings_48!B21/C21, CitationControl_34!C101/C102/C104/D104, Inputs_03!E187), 0 numeric movers, allowlist derived from diff.json; recorded in docs/release_evidence/wp39_freeze_record.md
- gates.excel_error_tokens
- 0
- gates.formula_fidelity
- 0 drifted of 1717
- gates.formulas_cached
- 1717/1717
- gates.key_set
- PASSED - the 155 recorded locations equal compute_outputs()'s emitted location set read from the v0.92 workbook, checked rather than carried forward from v2
- gates.label_provenance
- labels carried forward from outputs/v092_authoritative_validation_v2/; values re-read from this derivative and formulas from the source
- gates.libreoffice_err_tokens
- 0
- gates.literal_fidelity
- 0 drifted of 10167
- gates.mode
- Assumptions_02!B4 = DEFAULT
- gates.numeric_movement
- 0 across the whole v0.91 -> v0.92 span: 0 formula cells, 0 numeric literals and 0 cached numeric values differ anywhere in the file; 109 text cells do
- gates.sheet_count
- 50
- gates.source_sha_unchanged
- PASSED - source SHA identical before and after conversion
- regeneration
- cp <source> <scratch>/in/ ; soffice --headless --norestore --nolockcheck -env:UserInstallation=file://<scratch>/profile --convert-to 'xlsx:Calc MS Excel 2007 XML' --outdir <scratch>/out <scratch>/in/<copy>.xlsx
- source_workbook
- QA_Integrated_Model_v0_92_USER_SOURCE.xlsx
- source_workbook_sha256
- 4c7191452c0f8bd9c8ade1259e52f53b7b52817d69dd624c0b1c53ea7981580e
- supersedes
- outputs/v092_authoritative_validation_v2/ (source SHA 8d09c834...), invalidated by twelve text-only cell edits on 2026-09-07
- note
- v0.92 is a text-only build relative to v0.91. Measured cell by cell across all 50 sheets: 0 formula cells, 0 numeric literals and 0 cached numeric values differ; 109 text cells do. All 155 emitted targets therefore carry the same values, formulas AND labels as the v0.91 set, checked field by field rather than assumed. This set supersedes v2, whose identity stamp (source SHA 8d09c834...) died with the twelve text-only edits of 2026-09-07; RECALC_PROTOCOL.md forbids editing a recorded set in place. All 155 values and formulas are identical to v2 and the CSV report is byte-identical to v2's, so only the stamp moved. GATE NAMING: v0.92 v1 and v2 both recorded this file's recalc gate as 'recalc_fired'. The validation page contract requires 'gates.formulas_cached' (tests/test_browser_validation_page.py), so either set would have failed that test the moment it went live. Neither ever did. Named correctly here, matching the v0.91 set that has been serving /validation.
Validation Targets
All 155 targets, as recorded in the committed report
| Source location | Label | Workbook value | Code value | Delta | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Assumptions_02!E16 | Reference labor pool | 3000 | 3000 | 0.0 | PASS |
| Assumptions_02!E17 | Village capacity (excavated) | 25000 | 25000 | 0.0 | PASS |
| Assumptions_02!E94 | Aswan-Giza river corridor distance (km each way) | 890 | 890 | 0.0 | PASS |
| BargeTimber_43!B19 | 1129.08174446636 | 1129.0817444663596 | -4.547473508864641e-13 | PASS | |
| BargeTimber_43!B7 | Crew (mass) | 3.2 | 3.2 | 0.0 | PASS |
| BargeTimber_43!B9 | Payload subtotal (excl. hull) | 101.2 | 101.2 | 0.0 | PASS |
| ClosureRequirements_15!B15 | Share of 1.6M kingdom | 0.03125 | 0.03125 | 0.0 | PASS |
| ClosureRequirements_15!B16 | Share of 1.6M kingdom | 0.046875 | 0.046875 | 0.0 | PASS |
| ClosureRequirements_15!B17 | 0.0625 | 0.0625 | 0.0 | PASS | |
| ClosureRequirements_15!B18 | 0.078125 | 0.078125 | 0.0 | PASS | |
| ClosureRequirements_15!B19 | 0.09375 | 0.09375 | 0.0 | PASS | |
| ClosureRequirements_15!B20 | 0.125 | 0.125 | 0.0 | PASS | |
| ClosureRequirements_15!B5 | Current partial project-dedicated population | Required to close | 281642.857142857 | 281642.85714285716 | 1.7462298274040222e-10 | PASS |
| ClosureRequirements_15!B6 | Share of high-end 1.6M Old Kingdom population | Required to close | 0.176026785714286 | 0.17602678571428573 | -2.7755575615628914e-16 | PASS |
| ClosureRequirements_15!B8 | Current model vs 150k screen | 150,000 project-dedicated people | 1.87761904761905 | 1.8776190476190477 | -2.220446049250313e-15 | PASS |
| ClosureSensitivity_45!B10 | 22% male cohort | 85% farm | 0.896626420454545 | 0.8966264204545453 | 3.3306690738754696e-16 | PASS |
| ClosureSensitivity_45!B11 | 24% male cohort | 0.821907552083333 | 0.8219075520833332 | 2.220446049250313e-16 | PASS |
| ClosureSensitivity_45!B12 | 26% male cohort | 0.758683894230769 | 0.7586838942307691 | 1.1102230246251565e-16 | PASS |
| ClosureSensitivity_45!B13 | 28% male cohort | 0.7044921875 | 0.7044921874999999 | -1.1102230246251565e-16 | PASS |
| ClosureSensitivity_45!B14 | 30% male cohort | 0.657526041666667 | 0.6575260416666665 | -4.440892098500626e-16 | PASS |
| ClosureSensitivity_45!B18 | 20% male cohort | 85% farm | 0.78903125 | 0.7890312499999999 | -1.1102230246251565e-16 | PASS |
| ClosureSensitivity_45!B19 | 22% male cohort | 85% farm | 0.717301136363636 | 0.7173011363636362 | 2.220446049250313e-16 | PASS |
| ClosureSensitivity_45!B20 | 24% male cohort | 0.657526041666667 | 0.6575260416666665 | -4.440892098500626e-16 | PASS |
| ClosureSensitivity_45!B4 | Project rostered labor (live) | 47341.875 | 47341.875 | 0.0 | PASS |
| ClosureSensitivity_45!B9 | 20% male cohort | 85% farm | 0.9862890625 | 0.9862890624999998 | -2.220446049250313e-16 | PASS |
| ClosureSensitivity_45!C10 | 22% male cohort | 80% farm | 0.672469815340909 | 0.6724698153409092 | 2.220446049250313e-16 | PASS |
| ClosureSensitivity_45!C11 | 24% male cohort | 0.6164306640625 | 0.6164306640625001 | 1.1102230246251565e-16 | PASS |
| ClosureSensitivity_45!C12 | 26% male cohort | 0.569012920673077 | 0.5690129206730771 | 1.1102230246251565e-16 | PASS |
| ClosureSensitivity_45!C13 | 28% male cohort | 0.528369140625 | 0.5283691406250001 | 1.1102230246251565e-16 | PASS |
| ClosureSensitivity_45!C14 | 30% male cohort | 0.49314453125 | 0.4931445312500001 | 5.551115123125783e-17 | PASS |
| ClosureSensitivity_45!C18 | 20% male cohort | 80% farm | 0.5917734375 | 0.5917734375000001 | 1.1102230246251565e-16 | PASS |
| ClosureSensitivity_45!C19 | 22% male cohort | 80% farm | 0.537975852272727 | 0.5379758522727274 | 3.3306690738754696e-16 | PASS |
| ClosureSensitivity_45!C20 | 24% male cohort | 0.49314453125 | 0.4931445312500001 | 5.551115123125783e-17 | PASS |
| ClosureSensitivity_45!C9 | 20% male cohort | 80% farm | 0.739716796875 | 0.7397167968750001 | 1.1102230246251565e-16 | PASS |
| ClosureSensitivity_45!D10 | 75% farm | 22% male cohort | 0.537975852272727 | 0.5379758522727273 | 2.220446049250313e-16 | PASS |
| ClosureSensitivity_45!D11 | 24% male cohort | 0.49314453125 | 0.49314453125 | 0.0 | PASS |
| ClosureSensitivity_45!D12 | 26% male cohort | 0.455210336538462 | 0.45521033653846155 | -4.440892098500626e-16 | PASS |
| ClosureSensitivity_45!D13 | 28% male cohort | 0.4226953125 | 0.4226953124999999 | -5.551115123125783e-17 | PASS |
| ClosureSensitivity_45!D14 | 30% male cohort | 0.394515625 | 0.394515625 | 0.0 | PASS |
| DemographicClosure_46!A1 | DEMOGRAPHIC CLOSURE - SUSTAINED MOBILIZATION VS DOCUMENTED CAPACITY: can the kingdom survive the commitment? | DEMOGRAPHIC CLOSURE - SUSTAINED MOBILIZATION VS DOCUMENTED CAPACITY: can the kingdom survive the commitment? | None | PASS | |
| DemographicClosure_46!B10 | 20 | 20 | 0.0 | PASS | |
| DemographicClosure_46!B11 | 47341.875 | 47341.875 | 0.0 | PASS | |
| DemographicClosure_46!B14 | 0.1232861328125 | 0.1232861328125 | 0.0 | PASS | |
| DemographicClosure_46!B15 | 0.1408984375 | 0.1408984375 | 0.0 | PASS | |
| DemographicClosure_46!B16 | 0.6164306640625 | 0.6164306640625001 | 1.1102230246251565e-16 | PASS | |
| DemographicClosure_46!B19 | 54105 | 54105.0 | 0.0 | PASS | |
| DemographicClosure_46!B20 | 6763.125 | 6763.125 | 0.0 | PASS | |
| DemographicClosure_46!B21 | 81157.5 | 81157.5 | 0.0 | PASS | |
| DemographicClosure_46!B22 | 33815.625 | 33815.625 | 0.0 | PASS | |
| DemographicClosure_46!B23 | 2705.25 | 2705.25 | 0.0 | PASS | |
| DemographicClosure_46!B24 | 21942.8571428571 | 21942.85714285714 | 4.001776687800884e-11 | PASS | |
| DemographicClosure_46!B25 | 0.1232861328125 | 0.1232861328125 | 0.0 | PASS | |
| DemographicClosure_46!B26 | ONE IN EIGHT OF EVERY MATURING MALE COHORT, NATIONALLY, EVERY YEAR, FOR THE WHOLE BUILD - FOR ONE MONUMENT'S NON-FARM DEPARTMENTS ALONE | ONE IN EIGHT OF EVERY MATURING MALE COHORT, NATIONALLY, EVERY YEAR, FOR THE WHOLE BUILD - FOR ONE MONUMENT'S NON-FARM DEPARTMENTS ALONE | None | PASS | |
| DemographicClosure_46!B29 | 50000 | 50000 | 0.0 | PASS | |
| DemographicClosure_46!B30 | EPISODIC - NATIONAL EMERGENCY POSTURE, KINGDOM-WIDE + FOREIGN AUXILIARIES, DISBANDED AFTER EACH CAMPAIGN | EPISODIC - NATIONAL EMERGENCY POSTURE, KINGDOM-WIDE + FOREIGN AUXILIARIES, DISBANDED AFTER EACH CAMPAIGN | None | PASS | |
| DemographicClosure_46!B31 | 47341.875 | 47341.875 | 0.0 | PASS | |
| DemographicClosure_46!B32 | Project vs Weni maximum (concurrent basis) | 0.9468375 | 0.9468375 | 0.0 | PASS |
| DemographicClosure_46!B33 | Project vs Weni maximum (rostered basis) | 1.0821 | 1.0821 | 0.0 | PASS |
| DemographicClosure_46!B34 | CONTINUOUS FOR 20-30 YEARS - DOMESTIC NON-FARM POOL ONLY - ARMY MUST STILL EXIST ON TOP | CONTINUOUS FOR 20-30 YEARS - DOMESTIC NON-FARM POOL ONLY - ARMY MUST STILL EXIST ON TOP | None | PASS | |
| DemographicClosure_46!B35 | Test C status | APPROACHING THE MAXIMUM DOCUMENTED MOBILIZATION - AND HELD CONTINUOUSLY RATHER THAN LEVIED ONCE | APPROACHING THE MAXIMUM DOCUMENTED MOBILIZATION - AND HELD CONTINUOUSLY RATHER THAN LEVIED ONCE | None | PASS |
| DemographicClosure_46!B38 | Demographic closure verdict | DOES NOT CLOSE - SUSTAINED MOBILIZATION AT THE SCALE OF MAXIMUM DOCUMENTED CAPACITY, HELD CONTINUOUSLY | DOES NOT CLOSE - SUSTAINED MOBILIZATION AT THE SCALE OF MAXIMUM DOCUMENTED CAPACITY, HELD CONTINUOUSLY | None | PASS |
| DemographicClosure_46!B39 | The conventional model requires the kingdom to hold mobilization at the scale of its maximum documented emergency levy as a permanent 20-30 year baseline, consuming one in every 8 maturing males, before the army, temples, trade, administration, or any other major state construction program receives any labor. Weni's levy was raised once and disbanded; this one cannot be. | The conventional model requires the kingdom to hold mobilization at the scale of its maximum documented emergency levy as a permanent 20-30 year baseline, consuming one in every 8 maturing males, before the army, temples, trade, administration, or any other major state construction program receives any labor. Weni's levy was raised once and disbanded; this one cannot be. | None | PASS | |
| DemographicClosure_46!B41 | CONTROL/VERDICT LAYER ONLY - THIS SHEET DOES NOT ADD BURDEN TO M3 | CONTROL/VERDICT LAYER ONLY - THIS SHEET DOES NOT ADD BURDEN TO M3 | None | PASS | |
| DemographicClosure_46!B43 | Weni is 6th Dynasty, ~200 years after Khufu (later, larger state sets the ceiling HIGHER); the figure is rhetorical and read at maximum (a higher Weni makes the pyramid look easier). Palermo Stone (Snefru: 7,000 Nubian captives, 200,000 cattle) confirms the expeditionary-levy character of the OK military - temporary levies, no professional standing army. | Weni is 6th Dynasty, ~200 years after Khufu (later, larger state sets the ceiling HIGHER); the figure is rhetorical and read at maximum (a higher Weni makes the pyramid look easier). Palermo Stone (Snefru: 7,000 Nubian captives, 200,000 cattle) confirms the expeditionary-levy character of the OK military - temporary levies, no professional standing army. | None | PASS | |
| DemographicClosure_46!B5 | 1600000 | 1600000 | 0.0 | PASS | |
| DemographicClosure_46!B6 | 384000 | 384000.0 | 0.0 | PASS | |
| DemographicClosure_46!B7 | 54105 | 54105.0 | 0.0 | PASS | |
| DemographicClosure_46!B8 | 17.5 | 17.5 | 0.0 | PASS | |
| DemographicClosure_46!B9 | 1.14285714285714 | 1.1428571428571428 | 2.886579864025407e-15 | PASS | |
| DiagnosticIntegration_35!D5 | Feedback-solved food support population | Separate food-method fork | Active labor | FoodFeedback_28 | 261803.703742367 | 261803.70374236684 | -1.7462298274040222e-10 | PASS |
| DiagnosticIntegration_35!D6 | Sanitation / medical / cleaning labor | First-order support diagnostic | Active labor | SanitationMedical_29 | 1128 | 1128 | 0.0 | PASS |
| DiagnosticIntegration_35!E5 | Feedback-solved food support population | Rostered labor | FoodFeedback_28 | 261803.703742367 | 261803.70374236684 | -1.7462298274040222e-10 | PASS |
| Findings_09!A45 | F26 (River/harbor): Granite corridor support organization priced. | F26 (River/harbor): Granite corridor support organization priced. | None | PASS | |
| Findings_09!B3 | F1 (M1): Hauling rostered labor vs adjusted effective labor pool: | 8761 | 8761 | 0.0 | PASS |
| Findings_09!B4 | F2 (M2): On-site rostered labor, six priced departments: | 47316 | 47316 | 0.0 | PASS |
| Findings_09!B41 | Peak campaign corps of 1,601 active / 2,783 rostered enters M3 with no family multiplier (expedition concession). Shore-lift, refloat, and mid-route repair capability gaps remain findings, not priced mechanisms. | Peak campaign corps of 1,601 active / 2,783 rostered enters M3 with no family multiplier (expedition concession). Shore-lift, refloat, and mid-route repair capability gaps remain findings, not priced mechanisms. | None | PASS | |
| Findings_09!B42 | Felled barge acacia of 80.6 m3/yr enters felling/sawing/overhead labor. Cedar-import voyage and Giza overland haul lines are excluded because hulls are native acacia built at riverside yards - generous to the conventional scenario. | Felled barge acacia of 80.6 m3/yr enters felling/sawing/overhead labor. Cedar-import voyage and Giza overland haul lines are excluded because hulls are native acacia built at riverside yards - generous to the conventional scenario. | None | PASS | |
| Findings_09!B43 | Ruling 2026-07-09: annual-yield farmers (46,350 rostered) are excluded from the Test 1 numerator because their burden is priced in Test 2. Ruling MR-08 (v0.81) puts the share on a dimensionally consistent basis: concurrent ex-farmer labor against the standing non-farm pool. Ex-farmer share: 61.6% (2.5x the benchmark). The pre-correction rostered/standing figure of 70.4% is retained as a transparency line, as is the inclusive share. | Ruling 2026-07-09: annual-yield farmers (46,350 rostered) are excluded from the Test 1 numerator because their burden is priced in Test 2. Ruling MR-08 (v0.81) puts the share on a dimensionally consistent basis: concurrent ex-farmer labor against the standing non-farm pool. Ex-farmer share: 61.6% (2.5x the benchmark). The pre-correction rostered/standing figure of 70.4% is retained as a transparency line, as is the inclusive share. | None | PASS | |
| Findings_09!B45 | RiverHarbor_47 (Wave 6): barge crews, harbor gangs at both ends, and pilotage enter M3 as bodies only, anchored to the Diary of Merer - the mainstream's own document. The voyage schedule is feasible on paper (~1.1 barge-seasons for 30 pieces); the burden is the standing organization. Gates 1-4 in GraniteAswan_42 remain unresolved capability findings. Army-sourcing objection pre-answered: soldiers come from the same prime-age cohort; the numerator counts bodies. | RiverHarbor_47 (Wave 6): barge crews, harbor gangs at both ends, and pilotage enter M3 as bodies only, anchored to the Diary of Merer - the mainstream's own document. The voyage schedule is feasible on paper (~1.1 barge-seasons for 30 pieces); the burden is the standing organization. Gates 1-4 in GraniteAswan_42 remain unresolved capability findings. Army-sourcing objection pre-answered: soldiers come from the same prime-age cohort; the numerator counts bodies. | None | PASS | |
| Findings_09!B5 | F3 (M2): Implied village population vs excavated capacity of 25,000: | 281642.857142857 | 281642.85714285716 | 1.7462298274040222e-10 | PASS |
| Findings_09!B6 | F4 (M3, partial): Total project-dedicated population: | 533233.857142857 | 533233.8571428572 | 1.1641532182693481e-10 | PASS |
| Findings_09!C45 | RiverHarbor_47 / GraniteAswan_42 / SRC-MERER | RiverHarbor_47 / GraniteAswan_42 / SRC-MERER | None | PASS | |
| FoodFeedback_28!B46 | Net surplus per active farmer after own household support | 0.325252525252525 | 0.3252525252525249 | -1.1102230246251565e-16 | PASS |
| FoodFeedback_28!B54 | Total project-dedicated population if food loop passes | 1603796.90708902 | 1603796.9070890173 | -2.561137080192566e-09 | PASS |
| FoodFeedback_28!B58 | Required output per active farmer to preserve current farm net surplus share | Live value | 1.96632996632997 | 1.9663299663299665 | -3.552713678800501e-15 | PASS |
| FoodFeedback_28!B62 | Gross-output farmers implied by current net surplus share | 181126.088900207 | 181126.08890020655 | -4.3655745685100555e-10 | PASS |
| FoodSystem_13!B20 | Processing labor, total | 24171 | 24171 | 0.0 | PASS |
| GraniteAswan_42!B36 | 1601 | 1601.0 | 0.0 | PASS | |
| GraniteAswan_42!B37 | 2783 | 2783.0 | 0.0 | PASS | |
| GraniteAswan_42!B39 | INTEGRATED INTO M3 (Wave 5) - bodies only; capability gaps remain FINDINGS; river corridor support now priced in RiverHarbor_47 (Wave 6, v0.63) | INTEGRATED INTO M3 (Wave 5) - bodies only; capability gaps remain FINDINGS; river corridor support now priced in RiverHarbor_47 (Wave 6, v0.63) | None | PASS | |
| Inputs_03!B193 | Aswan-Giza river corridor (each way) | 890 | 890 | 0.0 | PASS |
| KingdomCapacity_17!B16 | Share of kingdom | 0.333271160714286 | 0.33327116071428575 | -2.220446049250313e-16 | PASS |
| KingdomCapacity_17!B18 | Current model / 150k screen | Above the 500,000 top band - Functionally kingdom-scale reorganization | 3.55489238095238 | 3.554892380952381 | 8.881784197001252e-16 | PASS |
| KingdomCapacity_17!B19 | Excess above 150k screen | Above the 500,000 top band - Functionally kingdom-scale reorganization | 383233.857142857 | 383233.85714285716 | 1.7462298274040222e-10 | PASS |
| KingdomCapacity_17!C16 | Share of kingdom | Manual source input from SRC-BUTZER-POP | 0.333271160714286 | 0.33327116071428575 | -2.220446049250313e-16 | PASS |
| KingdomCapacity_17!C18 | Current model / 150k screen | Capacity-band table below | 3.55489238095238 | 3.554892380952381 | 8.881784197001252e-16 | PASS |
| KingdomCapacity_17!C19 | Excess above 150k screen | Capacity-band table below | 383233.857142857 | 383233.85714285716 | 1.7462298274040222e-10 | PASS |
| Model_04!B12 | Share of adjusted effective labor pool | 0.247619047619048 | 0.24761904761904763 | -3.608224830031759e-16 | PASS |
| Model_04!B134 | TOTAL PROJECT-DEDICATED POPULATION | 533233.857142857 | 533233.8571428572 | 1.1641532182693481e-10 | PASS |
| Model_04!B135 | River/harbor corridor [Wave 6, bodies only] | 743 | 743.0 | 0.0 | PASS |
| Model_04!C12 | Share of adjusted effective labor pool | 0.914285714285714 | 0.9142857142857143 | 2.220446049250313e-16 | PASS |
| Model_04!D12 | Share of adjusted effective labor pool | 1.2 | 1.2 | 0.0 | PASS |
| NationalClosure_41!B12 | Project labor as share of the prime-age male cohort | 0.1408984375 | 0.1408984375 | 0.0 | PASS |
| NationalClosure_41!B13 | Project labor as share of the NON-FARM male labor pool | 0.6164306640625 | 0.6164306640625001 | 1.1102230246251565e-16 | PASS |
| NationalClosure_41!B14 | Test 1 status | EXCEEDS SINGLE-PROJECT MOBILIZATION CEILING | EXCEEDS SINGLE-PROJECT MOBILIZATION CEILING | None | PASS |
| NationalClosure_41!B18 | Farm surplus share (lever) | 0.25 | 0.25 | 0.0 | PASS |
| NationalClosure_41!B25 | Non-farm male labor share | 0.6164306640625 | 0.6164306640625001 | 1.1102230246251565e-16 | PASS |
| NationalClosure_41!B7 | Project-dedicated LABOR (rostered, all depts) | 100455 | 100455.0 | 0.0 | PASS |
| NationalClosure_41!B8 | 54105 | 54105.0 | 0.0 | PASS | |
| Objections_10!A21 | "The army crewed the barges and harbors." | "The army crewed the barges and harbors." | None | PASS | |
| Objections_10!B21 | Changes nothing. Soldiers are drawn from the same 384,000-man prime-age cohort; the Test 1 numerator counts bodies regardless of which state department supplies them. And an army standing crew duty on a 20-30 year monument corridor is not garrisoning borders or fielding campaigns - the demographic closure comparator (Weni) already prices what the kingdom could mobilize and for how long. | Changes nothing. Soldiers are drawn from the same 384,000-man prime-age cohort; the Test 1 numerator counts bodies regardless of which state department supplies them. And an army standing crew duty on a 20-30 year monument corridor is not garrisoning borders or fielding campaigns - the demographic closure comparator (Weni) already prices what the kingdom could mobilize and for how long. | None | PASS | |
| PersonCategoryMatrix_22!J17 | Domestic/process water included through WaterFeedback_21 | FoodSystem_13 capacity check | PASS / lower-bound | OPEN / lower-bound | Millers / bakers / brewers | PASS | PASS | None | PASS |
| ProcessingFuelContainers_30!B14 | Food-processing labor total | 24171 | 24171 | 0.0 | PASS |
| QAChecks_08!F12 | Total project-dedicated population ties across sheets. | Model_04 B131 = WorkforceLedger_05 C19 = Findings_09 B6 | M3 subtotal tie | 533233.857142857 | 533233.8571428572 | 1.1641532182693481e-10 | PASS |
| RampSystem_32!B106 | Total active ramp-system crew | 27.098131657063 | 27.098131657063032 | 3.197442310920451e-14 | PASS |
| RampSystem_32!B109 | Total material handled over build (m3) | 212500 | 212500.0 | 0.0 | PASS |
| RampSystem_32!B110 | Total material handled mass (t) | 382500 | 382500.0 | 0.0 | PASS |
| RampSystem_32!C106 | Total active ramp-system crew | 108.090658285315 | 108.09065828531514 | 1.4210854715202004e-13 | PASS |
| RampSystem_32!C109 | Total material handled over build (m3) | 1062500 | 1062500.0 | 0.0 | PASS |
| RampSystem_32!C110 | Total material handled mass (t) | 1912500 | 1912500.0 | 0.0 | PASS |
| RampSystem_32!D106 | Total active ramp-system crew | 311.471974855945 | 311.47197485594546 | 4.547473508864641e-13 | PASS |
| RampSystem_32!D109 | Total material handled over build (m3) | 3187500 | 3187500.0 | 0.0 | PASS |
| RampSystem_32!D110 | Total material handled mass (t) | 5737500 | 5737500.0 | 0.0 | PASS |
| RampSystem_32!E106 | Total active ramp-system crew | 622.943949711891 | 622.9439497118909 | -1.1368683772161603e-13 | PASS |
| RampSystem_32!E109 | Total material handled over build (m3) | 6375000 | 6375000.0 | 0.0 | PASS |
| RampSystem_32!E110 | Total material handled mass (t) | 11475000 | 11475000.0 | 0.0 | PASS |
| RiverHarbor_47!B24 | 557 | 557.0 | 0.0 | PASS | |
| RiverHarbor_47!B26 | 140 | 140.0 | 0.0 | PASS | |
| RiverHarbor_47!B28 | 46 | 46.0 | 0.0 | PASS | |
| RiverHarbor_47!B29 | TOTAL RIVER/HARBOR ROSTERED | 743 | 743.0 | 0.0 | PASS |
| RiverHarbor_47!B32 | 54605.7692307692 | 54605.76923076923 | 2.9103830456733704e-11 | PASS | |
| RiverHarbor_47!B33 | 54.6057692307692 | 54.605769230769226 | 2.842170943040401e-14 | PASS | |
| RiverHarbor_47!B34 | 300 | 300 | 0.0 | PASS | |
| RouteCapacity_12!B13 | TOTAL SIMULTANEOUS HAUL LANES | 7 | 7 | 0.0 | PASS |
| RouteCapacity_12!B5 | Headway per team (team + spec gap) | 48 | 48.0 | 0.0 | PASS |
| SanitationMedical_29!B34 | Combined first-order support labor | 1128 | 1128 | 0.0 | PASS |
| SanitationMedical_29!C34 | Combined first-order support labor | 1960.6647935616 | 1960.6647935615977 | -2.2737367544323206e-12 | PASS |
| SanitationMedical_29!D34 | Combined first-order support labor | 9803.32396780799 | 9803.323967807988 | -1.8189894035458565e-12 | PASS |
| ShapingSetting_33!C54 | Subtotal active labor × allowance | Rework/correction | 0.05 | 0.05 | 0.0 | PASS |
| ShapingSetting_33!D51 | Placement cadence × touched share | Labor rate | Final shaping/trim | 0.5 | 0.5 | 0.0 | PASS |
| ShapingSetting_33!D52 | Placement cadence × all blocks | Labor rate | Setting/alignment support | 0.4 | 0.4 | 0.0 | PASS |
| ShapingSetting_33!D54 | Subtotal active labor × allowance | Rework/correction | 108 | 108.0 | 0.0 | PASS |
| ShapingSetting_33!E51 | Active labor | Final shaping/trim | 25.7142857142857 | 25.714285714285715 | 1.4210854715202004e-14 | PASS |
| ShapingSetting_33!E52 | Active labor | Setting/alignment support | 82.2857142857143 | 82.28571428571429 | -1.4210854715202004e-14 | PASS |
| ShapingSetting_33!F51 | Rostered labor | Final shaping/trim | 44.6960059322553 | 44.69600593225527 | -2.842170943040401e-14 | PASS |
| ShapingSetting_33!F52 | Rostered labor | Setting/alignment support | 143.027218983217 | 143.02721898321687 | -1.4210854715202004e-13 | PASS |
| TimberLabor_40!B16 | Subtotal, direct timber labor | 819 | 819 | 0.0 | PASS |
| TimberLabor_40!B7 | TOTAL TIMBER PER YEAR | 4130.47695514362 | 4130.476955143621 | 9.094947017729282e-13 | PASS |
| TimberLabor_40!B8 | 80.6486960333114 | 80.64869603331141 | 1.4210854715202004e-14 | PASS | |
| VillageSufficiency_39!B11 | REQUIRED SUPPORT SUBTOTAL | 25299 | 25299 | 0.0 | PASS |
| WorkforceLedger_05!C16 | Grain transport | 150 | 150 | 0.0 | PASS |
| WorkforceLedger_05!C18 | On-site rostered total | 47316 | 47316 | 0.0 | PASS |
| WorkforceLedger_05!C20 | Off-site dedicated labor, rostered | 49613 | 49613 | 0.0 | PASS |
| WorkforceLedger_05!C21 | Total project-dedicated population | 533233.857142857 | 533233.8571428572 | 1.1641532182693481e-10 | PASS |
| WorkforceLedger_05!D20 | Off-site dedicated labor, rostered | 12360 | 12360 | 0.0 | PASS |